Journal Of Historical Review Vol 6 Number 1.pdf

(134490 KB) Pobierz
Historical
Review
John Bennett
I .
Was Orwell Right?
David Baxter
The Sedition Trial
o f
1944
Karl Otto Braun
German and American
Foreign Policy, 1933-1945
David
L.
Hoggan
Plato 's Dialectic v. Hegel and Marx
Walter N. Sanning
Soviet Scorched-Earth Warfare
Thies Christophersen
Auschwitz and West German Justice
-Book Reviews-
-News
and
Comment-
Volume
$&,
Number
One
SprjR8.
f
985
Historical
Review
VOLUME SIX, NUMBER
1
/
SPRING
1985
EDITORIAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
WALTER
B.
ALLENDE,
Ph.D.
University
of
Buenos
Aires
Buenos
Aires,
Argentina
GEORGE ASHLEY, Ph.D.
Los Angeles Unified School District
History Instructor
JOHN BENNETT
Australian Civil Liberties Union
Melbourne, Australia
ARTHUR R. BUTZ, Ph.D.
Northwestern University
Evanston, Illinois
ALBERT
J.
ECKSTEIN, Ph.D.
Private Research Consultant
ROBERT FAURISSON, Ph.D.
University of Lyon-2
Lyon, France
DITbIEB FELDERER
Revisionist History Magazine
Taby, Sweden
SAMUEL
E.
KONKIN 111
The New Libertarian
Long Beach, California
MARTIN
A.
LARSON,
Ph.D.
The
Spotlight
Washington,
D.C.
WILLIAM B. LINDSEY, Ph.D.
Research Chemist
CHARLES
LUTTON,
Ph.D.
American
Education
Institute
JAMES
J.
MARTIN,
Ph.D.
Ralph
Myles
Publishers
Colorado
Springs,
Colorado
REVILO P. OLIVER, Ph.D.
University of Illinois (Ret.)
Urbana, Illinois
WILHELM STAEGLICH, Dr. Jur. (Ret.)
Badenweiler, West Germany
UDO WALENDY, Diplo. Pol.
Verlag fuer Volkstum und
Zeitgeschichtsforschung
VlotholWeser, West Germany
MARK WEBER
The Historical Review Committee
ANDREAS R. WESSERLE, Ph.D.
Marquette University (Ret.)
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
The
Journal of
The Journal
elf
Historical Review is published quarterly by the
Institute for Historical Review, Post Office Box
1a6,
Torrance,
California
90505.
Subscriptions include the IHR Newsletter, an
eventful journal of interest to academic, and lay historical revi-
sionists, issued ei&t fimes per year on the alternate months of issue
price is
of The Journd
of
Hidorical Review. Combined subsc~ipfion
$30
per year,
$50
for
two
years, and
$70
for three years.
Add
$30
per
year for domestic first class delivery. Add
$5
per year for foreign
subscriptions. Add
$15
per year for overseas airmail delivery.
Remittances for subscriptions must be payable in U.S. dollars. Add
$5
if funds are drawn on a non-U.S. bank. Quantity subscription
and bulk issue rates are available on request. Appropriate
mannsc~ipts welcomed by the editor, and must be accompanied
are
by return postage.
Listed:
Library of Congress
British Library
PTLA Catalog
EBSCO Librarians Handhook
Ulrich's International Periodical Directory
Turner Periodical Catalog
Standard Periodical Directory
ISSN: 0195-6752
Institute for Historical
Review
P.O.
Box
1306, Torrance, California 90505, U.S.A.
Permission is hereby granted for reprints of any article contained
herein, providing that no changes or alterations are made prior to
printing, and also providing that the following attribution appears
with the article:
Reprinted by permission of The Journal of Historical Review, P.O.
Box
1306,
Torrance, California
90505,
United States of America.
Domestic subacriptian rate:
$30
per
year;Foreign
rate:
$35
per year.
Two copies of each printing should be submitted to the publisher
of The Journal of Historical Review.
Table of Contents
Volume
Six,
No.
1
Editorial Note
Mark Weber
Articles
Spring
1985
Orwell's '1984': Was Orwell Right?
John Bennett
The Great Sedition Trial of 1944:
A Personal Memoir
David Baxter
Reflections On German and American
Foreign Policy, 1933-1945
Karl Otto Braun
Plato's Dialectic v. Hegel and Marx:
An Evaluation of Five Revolutions
David
L.
Hoggan
Soviet Scorched-Earth Warfare
Walter N. Sanning
Reflections on Auschwitz and
West German Justice
Thies Christophersen
Book Review
Lawrence Dennis and Maximilian St. George
A
Trial on Trial:
The Great Sedition Trial of
1944
L.A.
Rollins
Historical News
and
Comment
Roosevelt's 'Secret Map' Speech
Mark Weber
About the Contributors
Editorial Note
Historical Revisionism and the
Legacy of George Orwell
uring the Second World War, George Orwell wrote a weekly
radio political commentary, designed to counter German and
Japanese propaganda in India, that was broadcast over the BBC
overseas service. His wartime work for the BBC was a major in-
spiration for his monumental novel, 1984. Very few readers of
1984 know, for example, that Orwell's attack against the perverse
double-talk language called Newspeak was based on the author's
revulsion against Basic English, an artificial language that
Churchill's wartime cabinet wanted the BBC to use in its overseas
propaganda. Similarly, Orwell's model for the lying Ministry of
Truth was the British wartime Ministry of Information, which
censored BBC broadcasts. The shorthand form, Minitrue, was
taken directly from the Ministry of Information telegraphic ad-
dress, Miniform.
Throughout his lifetime, the great English writer continually
questioned all "official" or "accepted" versions of history. As
early as
1945,
just after the end of the war in Europe, he expressed
doubts about the widespread stories of "gas oven" exterminations
[Notes on Nationalism). George Orwell was a revisionist. He
detested officially sanctioned atrocity and hate propaganda. If he
were alive today he would certainly be nauseated by the pervasive
Holocaust propaganda of our times. And as a staunch lifelong
supporter of free speech and open historical inquiry, he would un-
doubtedly defend the right of revisionist historians to present their
challenging views to the world.
It is worth noting that last July's devastating fire-bomb attack
against the offices of the Institute for Historical Review, the
foremost center of dissident historical inquiry, took place during
the year made immortal by 1984. The terrorist attack also forced
the rescheduling of the revisionist conference dedicated to
Orwell's memory. Symbolically, the July fire-bombing of the In-
stitute was an attack against the spirit of George Orwell in our
times.
Life in the western world today differs markedly from what
Orwell suggested it might be like in 1984. In contrast to the
squalid, puritanical and thoroughly regimented life of 1984's
Oceania, American life today is increasingly anarchic and self-
indulgent. But there are also many ominous similarities. Decep-
tive "Newspeak" terms are in wide use today. One of the most
odious examples is "affirmative action" which, despite its benign
D
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin